Would You Give Your Parents Money?
Personal Finance
There is a lot of interesting talk going around the PF community about giving money to your parents once you are established in your career. Here are some more detailed recent posts I have read:
- Him at Make Love, Not Debt
- Mapgirl at Mapgirlās Fiscal Challenge
- Frank the Financially Savvy Atheist
It seems that its ingrained in Asian culture particularly that the children will take care of the parents in retirement as appreciation for raising them. The children feel its necessary to send back what most of the comments indicate is something in the range of $200-$500 a month. This is even if the parents do not need it, or the children are on the border of poverty.
I’m third generation American and a mix of different backgrounds – Scottish, Russian, French-Canadian, Native American, among others. I would most definitely be described as Caucasian, and I grew up what would best be described as lower-middle class. My parents are still together and now they have better jobs plus my sister and I are out of the house, so they are more middle-middle class or even upper-middle class. My father is retired and my mother has about 3 more years before she can and receive all her benefits. They take 3-4 vacations a year and I would say are very comfortable financially.
My parents would never take money from me if I sent it to them. If I gave them cash on a birthday or holiday they would be disappointed that I did not put the effort into finding them a gift.
I certainly respect the importance of giving back. If my parents were worse off financially or in a bind I would have no problem helping them out. However in my family, the way we were raised they would feel embarrassed to take money from me.
I think its more of American working class culture that every generation wants their children to be better off than them. So most parents work to provide their offspring the best things they can when raising them. And once their children are grown, they want them to provide for their grandchildren more so than they provided for them so that is where the parents expect the money to be spent rather than go back to them.
Popularity: 1% [?]
Post a Comment »
| Recent Posts | Recent Comments | Popular Posts |
- Drew: @joann stanly: Have you looked at "Where's My Refund?" on t...
- joann stanly: i filed my taxes for 2009 end of Jan and thanks to H&R B...
- Renee: I filed online via H&R Block and I am supposed to get my...
- karen: i filed end of january. its august. had 1191 code. called...
- Cash Advance: This was a great and informative read! Fabulous work by th...


As a caucasian woman raised in America, I was surprised to hear of this custom of filial piety. I’d first heard of it several months after my marriage to a man of asian decent, as his parents expected him to begin monthly payments, and he felt he’d be a bad son if he did not provide this.
I think this is definately a difference in culture that should be discussed prior to marriage. It’s certainly a difficult thing for me to understand. In my culture we believe in helping out extended family when in trouble, but not just providing money for them because it’s filial. Especially when they, too, live in America where we have social security.